Vinesh Phogat's Disqualification Raises Questions About UWW Rules and Indian Support

Vinesh Phogat’s Disqualification Raises Questions About UWW Rules and Indian Support

In the aftermath of Vinesh Phogat’s controversial disqualification from the Paris Olympics, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) ruling has raised questions about the fairness and validity of the United World Wrestling (UWW) rules.

CAS arbitrator Annabelle Bennett acknowledged the “cryptic” nature of the second-day weigh-in list that disqualified Vinesh and criticized the “infelicitous” language of the UWW rules. She also deemed the consequences of the failed weigh-in as “draconian,” suggesting a more equitable solution could have been to eliminate Vinesh from the round she was ineligible for, rather than punishing her for rounds she had already competed in.

However, Bennett noted that the validity or reasoning behind the UWW’s rules was not challenged before CAS. This raises concerns about the lack of scrutiny given to the rules that ultimately led to Vinesh’s disqualification.

The UWW’s rules have been criticized for being loosely drafted and inconsistent. At the Paris Olympics, the team leader guide cited outdated rules, highlighting the need for clearer and more transparent regulations.

The article also questions the delayed legal response from Indian authorities to Vinesh’s disqualification. Despite the urgency of the situation, it took over eight hours for the Indian Olympic Association (IOA) to file a legal protest. This raises concerns about the effectiveness of the support system for Indian athletes at major sporting events.

Furthermore, the official Paris 2024 website and UWW’s final results book offer conflicting information about Vinesh’s absence from the brackets ladder. This lack of clarity adds to the confusion surrounding her disqualification.

The CAS ruling and subsequent analysis have highlighted the need for a thorough review of the UWW’s rules and the support mechanisms for Indian athletes. It remains to be seen whether the IOA or the Ministry of Sports will pursue further legal recourse or take steps to address the concerns raised by Vinesh’s disqualification.

Neha Sangwan Wins Under-17 World Wrestling Title, Inspired by Vinesh Phogat

Neha Sangwan Wins Under-17 World Wrestling Title, Inspired by Vinesh Phogat

Neha Sangwan, a young wrestler from Balai, Haryana, has achieved a remarkable feat by winning the Under-17 World title in the 57 kg category. This triumph comes just a week after she welcomed her idol, Vinesh Phogat, with a garland of currency notes.

Sangwan’s victory in Amman, Jordan, was a testament to her hard work and dedication. She defeated Japan’s So Tsutsui by technical superiority (10-0) in the final, becoming a world champion.

Her success is particularly significant as it aligns with Vinesh Phogat’s plea for more young girls to take up wrestling. Sangwan, who played a key role in Vinesh’s hero’s welcome in Balai, took the champion wrestler’s words to heart and delivered an inspiring performance.

“This title is for Vinesh didi and all the women wrestlers,” Sangwan said after the final bout. “Vinesh didi remains an inspiration for us all, and this world title will inspire the women wrestlers back in Balali village as well as India too.”

Sangwan’s journey began in 2016 when she joined Mahavir Phogat’s academy in Jhojhu Kalan. She quickly rose through the ranks, winning junior national medals and becoming a Haryana state champion. Seeking new challenges, she switched to the Krishan akhada, where coach Sajan Singh Mandola refined her skills.

Mandola focused on strengthening Sangwan’s defense, which had been a weakness, by increasing her speed and agility through rigorous training. Her hard work paid off, earning her the Asian Under-15 title in 2019 and a bronze medal at the World Cadet Wrestling Championships in Turkey.

Sangwan’s success continued this year, winning the Asian U-17 Wrestling Championship in Jordan and culminating in her recent world championship title. She credits Vinesh Phogat as a source of inspiration, whose achievements and encouragement have motivated her to strive for Olympic greatness.

Sangwan’s victory is not only a personal triumph but also a testament to the growing strength of women’s wrestling in India. It is a reminder that with hard work and determination, anything is possible.

Vinesh Phogat's Disqualification Overshadows Indian Olympic Success

Vinesh Phogat’s Disqualification Overshadows Indian Olympic Success

Ace Indian wrestler Vinesh Phogat’s journey at the 2024 Paris Olympics ended in heartbreak despite her valiant efforts. After reaching the final of the women’s 50kg freestyle wrestling event, Vinesh was disqualified due to a failed weigh-in by a mere 100 grams. The devastating news shattered the hopes of the entire nation, which had pinned its hopes on her for a medal.

Vinesh’s disqualification sparked outrage and disappointment, leading her to challenge the decision at the Court of Arbitration of Sport (CAS). However, the verdict went against her, further dampening her spirits. Despite the bitter turn of events, Vinesh’s determination and resilience have earned her the admiration and respect of her countrymen.

While Vinesh may not have officially secured a medal in Paris, her performance has significantly boosted her brand value. According to the Economic Times, her fee for endorsement deals has skyrocketed, reflecting her increased popularity and marketability. Before the Olympics, Vinesh reportedly charged around INR 25 lakh per deal. However, she now commands a fee in the range of INR 75 lakh to 1 crore from a single brand.

Vinesh’s success has also inspired other Indian athletes. Neeraj Chopra, the reigning Olympic gold medalist in javelin throw, returned home with a silver medal from Paris. Despite failing to repeat his gold medal performance, Chopra’s brand value has soared by 30-40%, reaching an estimated USD 40 million or INR 330 crore.

Manu Bhaker, another Indian shooting sensation, bagged two bronze medals in Paris. Her impressive performance has led to a surge in her brand value, resulting in a lucrative INR 1.5 crore deal with ThumbsUp. Before the Olympics, Manu charged around INR 25 lakh per endorsement deal. However, her Olympic success has seen her fee increase by six times.

The success of Vinesh, Neeraj, and Manu has not only brought glory to India but has also had a positive impact on the sports industry. Their achievements have inspired young athletes and ignited a passion for sports in the hearts of millions of Indians.

Vinesh Phogat Considers Political Debut in Haryana Assembly Elections

Vinesh Phogat Considers Political Debut in Haryana Assembly Elections

Ace wrestler Vinesh Phogat, who narrowly missed out on an Olympic gold medal in Paris, is reportedly considering a foray into politics. Sources close to her have hinted at the possibility of her contesting the upcoming Haryana Assembly elections.

Despite her previous statements that she would not pursue active politics, Vinesh has reportedly been approached by several political parties eager to secure her support. The wrestler’s impressive performance at the Olympics, where she was disqualified from the final due to being overweight, has garnered significant attention and made her a potential political asset.

Vinesh’s return to India was met with a rousing welcome, with Congress MP Deepender Hooda and other family members garlanding her at the Indira Gandhi International Airport. However, the party she intends to join remains uncertain.

Sources close to the Phogat family have suggested that Vinesh could potentially face off against her cousin, Babita Phogat, in the Haryana Assembly elections. Additionally, Bajrang Punia and Yogeshwar Dutt, two other prominent wrestlers, may also contest the elections.

Vinesh’s decision to consider politics has sparked speculation about her future in wrestling. In a recent social media post, she hinted at a possible return to the sport, despite her earlier decision to retire after the Paris Olympics disqualification.

The wrestler’s disqualification from the gold medal match due to weight issues has raised questions about the challenges faced by female athletes in India. Vinesh has been an outspoken advocate for women’s rights and has used her platform to highlight the need for better support and opportunities for female athletes.

As Vinesh weighs her options, her fans and supporters eagerly await her decision on both her political and sporting future. Her potential entry into politics could have a significant impact on the Haryana Assembly elections and the broader landscape of Indian politics.

CAS Upholds Vinesh Phogat's Disqualification from Olympics

CAS Upholds Vinesh Phogat’s Disqualification from Olympics

The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has ruled against Indian wrestler Vinesh Phogat in her appeal against her disqualification from the 50kg wrestling event at the Paris Olympics 2024. In a detailed 24-page verdict, CAS described the United World Wrestling’s (UWW) rules for punishing athletes who fail the second-day weigh-in as “draconian” but ultimately upheld the decision to disqualify Phogat.

Phogat had cleared the weigh-in process on the first day of her event but was found 100gm overweight on the second day, the day of her gold medal bout. As per UWW rules, wrestlers must clear the weigh-in on both days of the competition. While the UWW allows a 2kg weight tolerance in many international competitions, there is no such buffer at the Olympics.

In her appeal, Phogat argued that she should be awarded a joint silver medal with Cuban wrestler Yusneylis Guzman Lopez, who lost to her in the semifinals but was promoted to the summit clash following her disqualification. However, CAS dismissed her appeal, stating that it was Phogat’s responsibility to ensure she was under the permissible limit during both days of the competition.

CAS acknowledged that the consequences of failing the second weigh-in were severe, but it emphasized that Phogat had voluntarily entered the 50kg weight category and was aware of the weight requirements. The court also noted that Phogat had previously competed under the UWW rules and had not raised any concerns about the weight requirements.

Phogat’s disqualification from the Olympics was a major disappointment for India, as she had become the first Indian woman wrestler to qualify for an Olympic final. Her stunning victory over legendary Japanese wrestler Yui Susaki had raised hopes of a medal, but her disqualification shattered those dreams.

Despite the CAS ruling, Phogat has received a hero’s welcome upon her return to India. Her performance at the Olympics has inspired many young wrestlers and demonstrated her resilience and determination.

CAS Upholds Vinesh Phogat's Disqualification for Overweight

CAS Upholds Vinesh Phogat’s Disqualification for Overweight

The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has released the detailed verdict of the sole arbitrator, Annabelle Bennett, who dismissed Vinesh Phogat’s appeal for a silver medal after her disqualification for being overweight in the weigh-in before the final at the Paris Olympics.

Bennett acknowledged the persuasiveness of the Indian side’s arguments but emphasized that the clear-cut rules left no room for leeway. The rules state that wrestlers must remain eligible throughout the competition, from entry to the finals. Failure to do so results in elimination without ranking.

Vinesh, who won three bouts to reach the final, was marginally overweight at the mandatory second weigh-in the next morning before the gold medal bout. She argued that the excess weight was due to factors such as the menstrual cycle, water retention, and insufficient time to reduce her weight due to travel.

However, Bennett noted that the rules are clear and do not allow for any tolerance. Athletes are responsible for ensuring they remain below the weight limit.

Vinesh’s appeal for a shared silver medal was also dismissed as it was not within the arbitrator’s power. The UWW rules state that once a wrestler becomes ineligible during the competition, the consequences of elimination without ranking apply.

Bennett expressed sympathy for Vinesh’s situation, calling the disqualification rule “draconian.” She suggested that a fairer solution would be to eliminate the wrestler from the round for which they were found ineligible, rather than the entire competition.

The detailed verdict provides insights into the UWW’s weigh-in rules and the consequences of failing to meet the weight limit. It highlights the importance of athletes adhering to the regulations and the challenges they may face in maintaining their weight during competitions.

CAS Upholds Vinesh Phogat's Disqualification for Overweight

CAS Upholds Vinesh Phogat’s Disqualification for Overweight

The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) has upheld its decision to disqualify Indian wrestler Vinesh Phogat from the Paris Olympics final due to being overweight. In a detailed ruling, the CAS stated that athletes are solely responsible for ensuring they remain below the weight limit, with no exceptions allowed.

Phogat’s disqualification stemmed from being 100 grams overweight on the morning of the women’s 50kg freestyle final. She had appealed the decision, arguing that the excess weight was minimal and could be attributed to factors such as water retention. However, the CAS rejected her appeal, citing the clear rules regarding weight limits.

“The Rules are clear as to the weight limit and are the same for all participants. There is no tolerance provided for – it is an upper limit. It does not even allow for the weight of the singlet. It is clearly up to an athlete to ensure that they remain below that limit,” the CAS stated.

Phogat’s disqualification sparked controversy, with the Indian Olympic Association (IOA) expressing disappointment. However, the CAS emphasized that the rules are impartial and must be adhered to by all athletes.

In her appeal, Phogat had requested a joint silver medal with Cuban wrestler Yusneylis Guzman Lopez, who lost to her in the semifinals but was promoted to the final after Phogat’s disqualification. The gold medal was won by American Sarah Ann Hildebrandt.

The CAS’s decision serves as a reminder to athletes of the importance of adhering to weight limits and the consequences of exceeding them. It also highlights the impartial nature of the CAS in upholding the rules of sports.

Vinesh Phogat Receives Grand Welcome Despite Olympic Disqualification

Vinesh Phogat Receives Grand Welcome Despite Olympic Disqualification

Vinesh Phogat’s Olympic journey has been a rollercoaster of emotions. After becoming the first Indian woman wrestler to reach an Olympic final, her dreams were shattered when she was disqualified for being 100 grams overweight on the morning of the gold medal bout. Despite her disappointment, Vinesh has received an outpouring of support and adulation upon her return to India.

However, her husband, Somvir Rathee, has raised concerns about false claims of cash prizes being made by certain organizations. In a social media post, Rathee clarified that Vinesh has not received any money from these entities. He urged well-wishers to refrain from spreading false news, as it harms both Vinesh and social values.

Despite the setback, Vinesh was greeted with a grand welcome at the IGI airport in Delhi. Hundreds of supporters gathered to show their solidarity, including fellow wrestlers Bajrang Punia and Sakshi Malik. Vinesh expressed her gratitude for the support, saying, “I thank the entire country for support.”

Vinesh’s caravan then proceeded to her native village in Haryana, where she was met with more well-wishers. Congress leader Deepender Hooda presented her with a mace, a symbol of victory, which brought tears to her eyes.

Vinesh’s disqualification has sparked discussions about the strict weight regulations in wrestling. Some experts have argued that the 100-gram margin is too narrow and can lead to unfair disqualifications. Others have emphasized the importance of adhering to the rules and maintaining a healthy weight.

Despite the controversy, Vinesh remains a role model for aspiring wrestlers and a source of inspiration for all Indians. Her resilience and determination have earned her the respect and admiration of the nation.

Vinesh Phogat's Olympic Heartbreak Inspires Outpouring of Love and Support

Vinesh Phogat’s Olympic Heartbreak Inspires Outpouring of Love and Support

Vinesh Phogat, India’s wrestling star, has received an outpouring of love and support since her return from the Paris Olympics 2024. Despite the heartbreak of being disqualified from the women’s 50kg wrestling final, Vinesh’s resilience and determination have inspired the nation.

Upon her arrival at the New Delhi airport on Saturday, Vinesh was greeted by a throng of supporters. Her journey to her family’s village, Babali, was a testament to the immense admiration she holds in her community. Thousands lined the streets, cheering and showering her with affection.

On Monday, Vinesh celebrated Raksha Bandhan with her brother. A heartwarming video emerged on social media, showing Vinesh holding a bundle of Rs 500 notes. “I am almost 30 years old. Last year he gave me Rs 500. After that this (points to a bundle of currency note). He has earned this much money only in his whole life (jokingly), which he has given to me,” Vinesh said, eliciting laughter from her brother.

Vinesh’s journey from Delhi to Balali was a testament to her popularity. She was felicitated by supporters and ‘khap’ panchayats in several villages, extending her 135km-long journey to nearly 13 hours.

Despite the disappointment of her disqualification, Vinesh has remained steadfast in her resolve to fight for justice. Her appeal against the disqualification was rejected by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), but she has vowed to continue her battle against the Wrestling Federation of India (WFI).

“Our fight has not ended and it will continue,” Vinesh declared. “We have been fighting a battle for one year. It will continue and by God’s grace, the truth will prevail.”

Vinesh’s unwavering spirit has resonated with the nation. She has become a symbol of resilience and determination, inspiring countless young athletes to pursue their dreams. Her legacy as a two-time CWG gold medallist, Asian Games champion, and eight-time Asian Championships medallist will continue to inspire generations to come.

Vinesh Phogat Receives Grand Welcome After Olympic Disqualification

Vinesh Phogat Receives Grand Welcome After Olympic Disqualification

Celebrated Indian wrestler Vinesh Phogat received a rousing welcome upon her return to India after her controversial disqualification at the Paris Olympics. Hundreds of supporters gathered outside the Indira Gandhi International Airport in Delhi, expressing their solidarity with Phogat, who was disqualified for being overweight after reaching the 50kg final.

The outpouring of support continued during a roadshow from Delhi to Phogat’s native village of Balali. Along the 135km journey, she was felicitated by supporters and ‘khap’ panchayats in several villages, extending the trip to nearly 13 hours.

In Balali, Phogat was greeted with a gold medal by community elders, a testament to the pride and admiration she has brought to her village. Despite the late hour, a massive crowd attended the felicitation ceremony.

Overwhelmed by the reception, Phogat expressed her gratitude and her desire to train women wrestlers from Balali to achieve even greater success than herself. She emphasized the importance of support and encouragement for aspiring female wrestlers.

Phogat’s disqualification had sparked outrage in India and the wrestling world. Her appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) was rejected, but her determination and resilience have inspired many.

Upon reaching her village, Phogat addressed the gathering, expressing her hope that someone from Balali would surpass her achievements. She urged the community to support women wrestlers and provide them with the necessary resources to excel.

Phogat’s journey has been marked by both triumph and adversity. She is a two-time Commonwealth Games gold medalist, Asian Games champion, and has won eight Asian Championships medals. Her disqualification at the Olympics was a setback, but it has not diminished her spirit or her commitment to the sport.

Phogat’s return to India has been a celebration of her achievements and a reminder of the power of resilience and determination. Her story continues to inspire aspiring wrestlers and serves as a testament to the indomitable spirit of Indian athletes.

Home
Shop
Wishlist0
Back to Top

Search For Products

Product has been added to your cart