The “impact player” rule, introduced in the Indian Premier League (IPL) in 2023, has sparked a debate among cricket experts. While some believe it adds excitement to the game, others argue that it undermines the role of all-rounders.
IPL chairman Arun Dhumal has acknowledged the mixed reactions to the rule, stating that the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) is open to reviewing it after the current season. “We will definitely look into it and discuss with all parties involved,” Dhumal said.
The rule allows teams to substitute a player from their bench with an “impact player” at any point during the match. This player can be used as a batter, bowler, or fielder, providing teams with tactical flexibility.
However, critics argue that the rule marginalizes all-rounders, who are now less likely to get a chance to bowl or bat. India captain Rohit Sharma, who plays for Mumbai Indians in the IPL, has expressed his concerns about the impact on all-rounders.
“I am not a big fan of the impact sub rule,” Sharma said. “It is going to hold all-rounders back. Cricket is played by 11 players, not 12. You are taking so much from the game to make it entertaining for people around.”
Sharma believes that the rule gives teams an unfair advantage if they bat well and don’t lose wickets, as they can add another bowler to their lineup. He also argues that it reduces the importance of the No. 7 and No. 8 batters.
Despite the concerns raised by Sharma and others, Dhumal emphasized that the BCCI is open to feedback and will consider all perspectives before making a decision on the future of the rule.
