Australia’s Test team faces a crucial decision ahead of the Border-Gavaskar series against India: who will open the batting alongside Usman Khawaja? Steven Smith’s four-match stint as an opener has been met with mixed reviews, prompting speculation about potential alternatives.
Despite Smith’s initial request to open, his performance in New Zealand has raised concerns. His scores of 31, 0, 11, and 9 on pitches favoring new-ball bowlers have cast doubt on his suitability for the role.
Coach Andrew McDonald has stated that the incumbent top six from the New Zealand series will remain for the first Test against India, but discussions are ongoing. If Smith is not retained as an opener, several options emerge.
Marnus Labuschagne:
Labuschagne could swap positions with Smith, moving from No. 3 to open. He has experience opening in first-class cricket, including a century at the WACA in 2016. However, moving Labuschagne from his successful position at No. 3 may not be ideal.
Cameron Green:
Green was considered as a potential opener before Warner’s retirement. He has the skills to do it, but his heavy bowling workload and preference for No. 4 make it an undesirable option.
Travis Head:
Khawaja has suggested Head as the best partner for him, allowing Smith to return to No. 4. Head has opened in Test cricket in India, but his mediocre record against spin in the subcontinent is a concern.
Mitchell Marsh:
Marsh has made it clear that he is not comfortable moving to the top of the order. His technique is not suited to batting against the new ball, and his bowling will be crucial throughout the summer.
The selectors face a difficult decision. Smith’s desire to open must be balanced against the team’s overall balance and the strengths of the other candidates. The upcoming Shield matches will provide further insights into the team’s plans.
