DRS Accuracy Concerns Raised by Harbhajan Singh
Former Indian spinner Harbhajan Singh has expressed skepticism about the accuracy of the Decision Review System (DRS) in judging the bounce of the ball. Speaking on the 180 Not Out podcast, Harbhajan questioned the system’s ability to determine the exact trajectory of the ball, particularly in relation to the wicket.
Harbhajan’s concerns stem from the fundamental principle of cricket, which dictates that any ball that hits the wicket results in a dismissal. However, he believes that DRS often fails to adhere to this rule, leading to inconsistent and sometimes questionable decisions.
“I’m not fully inclined to believe that it is entirely accurate because it cannot judge the bounce of the ball and how much it is bouncing,” Harbhajan said. “Another thing that bothers me is that when we start playing cricket in the neighborhood, we are shown the wicket and told that if the ball hits the wicket, you’re out.”
Harbhajan also criticized the inconsistency in applying DRS decisions by umpires. He cited instances where umpires have upheld not-out decisions despite clear evidence from the technology that the ball hit the stumps.
“If the umpire has given a not out, and DRS clearly shows the ball hitting the stumps, it should be given out,” Harbhajan argued. “But we sometimes use the umpire’s decision and retain the not out verdict. Aap technology ko la bhi rahe ho aur uski baat bhi nahi maan rahe (You are bringing in technology but not accepting its decision).”
In contrast, former India pacer S Sreesanth expressed a more positive view towards technology in cricket, but with some reservations. He acknowledged the potential benefits of technology in improving decision-making, but cautioned against relying on it completely.
“Technology, if used wisely, is brilliant because you’ve got to accept the change, but don’t depend on it completely,” Sreesanth said.
The debate over the accuracy and consistency of DRS continues to stir controversy in cricket. The recent incident involving Virat Kohli’s dismissal in the 2024 Indian Premier League has reignited the discussion about the efficacy of technology in the sport.
